In her past life, Nancy Levine was betrayed when her husband, Sawyer Penn, faked his death to take his twin Reuben's place with Reuben's wife—leaving Nancy to suffer while her daughter starved. Reborn on the day Reuben drowns, she wipes Sawyer from her life, enlists her foster brother Caleb, exposes the Penns, and finally builds a peaceful life with Caleb, who has loved her all along.